Indianapolis Carmelites to Close Monastery

 They are perhaps best known in the post Vatican II church for producing an inclusive language Liturgy of the Hours, that was used by a number of women religious. But before then they were cloistered and the recipients a wealthy Lousiville’s family’s money whose daughter was the founding nun of this particular monastery. That led to the building of this very interesting monastery, of which you get a glimpse in the above picture. I visited them some years ago and prayed Vespers with them, they were miffed at a piece that Our Sunday Visitor had written against the inclusive version they had produced, but nice to me–something that would have been impossible if they were still cloistered. They were nice women–almost all from different communities that had closed after experimenting with similar reforms. Sadly, now another chapter closes on the failed reforms which led many to abandon the charisms that attracted them to their particular religious order in the first place. Brings to mind the Book of Revelation, “You have forgotten your first love.” From WTHR in Indianapolis:

The Carmelites of Indianapolis have called Indianapolis home for 75 years.  They’ve lived in a monastery on Cold Spring Road doing God’s work through prayer and contemplation.

The nine Catholic sisters, whose median age is in the mid-70s, are moving. This summer they’ll relocate to a building on the Franciscan sisters’ property in Oldenburg, Indiana.

Prioress Sister Jean Alice McGoff said of the decision, “It takes a lot to run a place like this. Even though we’ve been able to live a life of prayer, we felt it was better to make the transition when we could do it for ourselves, we have the energy and we’re well.”

Also key is the Archdiocese of Indianapolis’ offer to buy their property for a seminary. The seminary will house men preparing for the priesthood at nearby Marian College.

Sister Jean Alice said,”The fact this building would continue to be a house of worship was important to us.  And we just felt it was a gift of God.”

She and the other sisters are no strangers to change. Until the early 60s, they were cloistered, living behind the thick stone walls of the monastery, which they themselves maintained.

“We were always faithful to our life of prayer, but we did a lot of work to save money,” Sister Jean Alice said. “I learned to push a wheelbarrow, dig up and cut down trees, transplant trees.  I learned to use all kinds of tools – hammers and saws.”

The sisters greeted visitors through a window with a thick screen, venturing out only for emergencies. That began to change in the mid-60s along with changes in the Catholic church.  The Carmelites gradually opened up, having face-to-face interactions with visitors. They also began watching TV and reading the newspaper.

While the sisters still lead simple, mostly private lives, they’re well read and, well connected thru their website, praythenews.org.

The sisters launched it as a way to introduce women to their way of life.

“Sometimes when you set out to do a goal, something else develops and that’s what happened,” Sister Jean Alice said.

While the website didn’t result in any new vocations, it did draw worldwide attention, which was a bit overwhelming for the publicity-shy sisters.

Sister Jean Alice laughed, recalling one of the media requests: “and now we were going to be on the Today Show and I just said, ‘Sisters, please don’t do this!'”

As they do every Sunday, the sisters invited friends and visitors to join them for Easter Mass, but this time there were special prayers for the sisters. Visiting priest Father Tom Widner noted their leaving and influence on the community.

“They’re just warm and affectionate and very considerate of people and loving. It’s a loss for the local church and Indianapolis,” he said.

Mary Ann Grogan, who’s known the sisters for years, talked about the monastery being “a quiet space…and we like to think we take some of their goodness into our busy world.”

Carolyn Fay agreed. “On a personal note, these sisters are my sisters and I’ll miss them very much. They’ve introduced me to so many ways of looking at spirituality and finding God in each other.”

Asked what message she wanted to share, Sister Jean Alice said, “There’s a reverence in me and I think all the sisters, for every human being no matter who they are, we are all God-bearers.”

She said while the sisters would take down their web site after moving, they would continue to do God’s work, just from a different house of prayer.

Advertisements

One Response

  1. I suspect some times that this is the direction these communities wanted to go.

    I can think of one order that is still rather large (about 600) – although they are all septugenarians – that hasn’t taken a novice in who took final vows in TWO DECADES!

    This community about which I am thinking knows that they are collectively on the way out – with a short stop in the nursing homes somewhere – and are making no efforts to pass on what they have. If anything, they seem to be concerned about the “wrong” sort of sisters either (1) entering or (2) getting their hands on the property. And by that I mean they would rather die out than see non-liberals get their hands on the properties and schools they own.

    I feel sorry for them – almost. They wander from new (old) community to new (old) communities, getting greyer and greyer and greyer… But at least by selling off their patrimony they have enough money just for themselves.

    In a real way, they remind me of European nobility who are drinking the last of their wine cellar…

    It is all too sad.

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: