The Problem with Catholic Bible Study

Stated well and right on the mark by Summa Contra Mundum:

When I taught scripture in high school, the students had a one-sentence summary of what they learned of the bible: “We learn that nothing that the bible says really happened really happened.” That’s the impression they got from four years of historical criticism.

I myself taught high school and heard exactly the same thing when I tried to present the “Fallen State” of humanity according to Genesis to Juniors who had Scripture as Freshman. I do find some hope that the current Pontiff writes about the deficiencies of the historical critical method and its effect on preaching and catechesis.

Michael Dubruiel – 2005